The party met up on the docks, where Mynister Tavin christened the new sail boat that had been paid for and built by the Council. The party boarded, ready to set sail, but due to lack of wind, the boat did nothing. Then taking meteorological advice, the Mynister discovered it would be a few days before they had any wind, so the party disbanded, and reconvened at a later date.
One a nice windy day, the party set sail on HMS Butterworth, and ventured out into the unknown waters of Lake Mysthaven. Hawthorn took the wheel, directing the boat through the waters, and the party soon found themselves near a mysterious rocky island which looked abandoned apart from a shallow trough in the centre. The Mynister led a small party ashore in the row boat, accompanied by Teddy and Eira, where they discovered that within the trough sat a trident and some blue gems. The Mynister took the trident, while Teddy distributed the gems among the party.
However, having done so, some undead fish like humanoids (now called Finbies) emerged and began to attack the group. A number also appeared under water, and swarmed the heroes on the boat, causing Laucian to jump ship and swim to his companions ashore. The Finbies were eventually defeated, and the party retreated to the safety of their boat.
While aboard, the Mynister tested his new trident, and found he could control fish.
The party spent another few days on the Butterworth, exploring the lake, where they found another island with a cave, and a third island that was sandy and uninteresting. Sailing north east, the party saw lights on the shore, and sailing closer to investigate, were soon met my numerous small multi-coloured frogs on canoes. These were Grung.
Laucian and Teddy went ashore (the Mynister who wanted to attend too was unable to), and were taken to meet the Chief Grung who was gold. Teddy and Laucian engaged in struggled conversation with him, due to the magical conch that he held to his ears. They agreed with the Chief that they would help the Grung by assisting them in destroying the Bullywugs, who they were part enslaving, part killing. They persuaded him by talk of shinies (the blue gems found earlier) as well as making some Bullywug slaves fall asleep (to appear dead), who they then took back to HMS Butterworth.
The party sailed back to Mysthaven with the Bullywug as captives, trying to learn a few words from them, and anything about them. While the Mynister wanted to take them back to Mysthaven, a number of the party (particularly Teddy) did not like this idea. On the final night before the party reached Mysthaven, somebody released the Bullywugs from their hold.